Silly Goose

Guide · Updated · 5 min read

Nanny or daycare in Boston?

The short answer

For one baby, daycare usually costs less than a full-time nanny. Infant center care in Massachusetts averaged about $27,000 a year in 2025, with Boston higher (around $31,000), while a full-time nanny is often $55,000–70,000+ before employer taxes. With two kids or a nanny share, the gap shrinks fast. Cost is only half of it: hours, sick days and waitlists often decide it.

We did both in one year: a nanny, then daycare when our nanny had a family emergency. Here's what we wish we'd seen side by side.

The cost, side by side

Daycare (infant, center)Full-time nanny
Typical yearly costabout $27,000 statewide (2025); around $31,000 in Bostonabout $55,000–70,000+ in wages
Extra costsRegistration, supplies, late pickupsEmployer taxes (~8–9%), workers' comp, agency fee if used
Second childRoughly doubles the costUsually a modest raise
Where the numbers come fromChild Care Aware of America (2025 state prices); DaycareCalc Boston estimateBoston wage sources (see wages)

Massachusetts has the highest average price for infant center care of any state that reported data in 2025, according to Child Care Aware of America. You can download the Massachusetts fact sheet from their report.

When daycare usually wins

  • One child, especially an infant or toddler: it's usually the cheaper option.
  • Socializing and structure: classrooms, routines, other kids.
  • Reliability: no single point of failure if a caregiver is sick.
  • Simplicity: you're a customer, not an employer. No payroll, no taxes, no work agreement.

When a nanny usually wins

  • Two or more kids: one nanny can cost less than two daycare spots.
  • Long or odd hours: daycare hours are fixed; a nanny can match your schedule.
  • Sick days: daycare sends sick kids home; a nanny can stay with them.
  • No waitlist: infant daycare spots in Boston can take months to open up.
  • Nanny share: two families split one nanny, which often brings the per-family cost close to daycare.

Questions that usually decide it

  1. How many kids will need care in the next two years?
  2. What hours do you actually need, including commutes?
  3. What happens on a sick day? Who stays home?
  4. How soon do you need care? Get on daycare waitlists early, even if you're unsure.
  5. Do you want to be an employer? A nanny means payroll and paperwork (see the taxes guide).

Ways families bring the cost down

  • Nanny share with a neighbor.
  • Part-time nanny + part-time daycare.
  • Dependent care FSA: up to $7,500 pre-tax in 2026, for either daycare or a nanny.
  • Child and dependent care tax credit on part of your costs.

There's no wrong answer. Many families, including ours, end up trying more than one.

Want to try your own numbers? Estimate your cost →

Sources

  1. Child Care Aware of America: Child Care in America, 2025 Price & Supply · as of 2025 prices, published May 2026
  2. DaycareCalc: daycare and nanny cost in Boston, MA (modeled from market rate data) · as of 2026

What would it cost your family?

See your own all-in range, with every figure sourced.

Estimate your cost →